1
Scientific Director of Human Reproduction, Jalandhar, Punjab, India
2
Scientific Director, Ex-Rotunda-A Centre for Human Reproduction 672, Kalpak Garden, Perry Cross Road, Mumbai, India
3
Consultant Neurologist, Swami Satyanand Hospital, Near NawiKachehri, Baradri, Ladowali
Road, Jalandhar, Punjab, India
Corresponding author details:
Kulvinder Kochar Kaur
Scientific Director of Human Reproduction 721, G.T.B. Nagar
Punjab,India
Copyright:
© 2020 Kochar KK, et al. This is
an open-access article distributed under
the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution 4.0 international License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the
original author and source are credited.
Overweight and obesity in adults and children has escalatedat an astonishing rate in
the past few decades bringing in a lot of the cost burden [1]. Increased Adipose Tissue (AT)
as well as ectopic fat collection is typical properties of obesity which results in associated
comorbidities like, Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM), Hypertension, dyslipidemia.Recently
Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Diseases (NAFLD) has become the commonest chronic liver disease
correlated with obesity [2]. Right now the therapy of obesity concentrates on lifestyle
changes which include exercise.No reduction in obesity incidence has occurred in spite of
lifestyle as well as diet changes over the past 3 decades [1]. We have reviewed multiple ways
of treating obesity medically that includes Qsymia,Contrave, Thylakoids,GLP-1 agonists
,BAT thermogenesis enhancement utilizing mirabegron, probiotics etc but none have been
of help in maintenance of weight reduction for long term other than Bariatric Surgery(BS)
[3-9]. Further with escalating obesity liver disorders are increasing remarkably with no
effective way of treating them .All over the world work is being done at war footing with
the enhanced rates of liver transplants needed inthose under 50 yrs [10,11]. Thus we have
further tried to present the advances done in working out some medical therapy to prevent
propagation of NAFLD and halt it further to not progress till Nonalcoholic Steato Hepatitis
(NASH) level,cirrhosis and Hepatocellular Carcinoma (HCC).
Thus we did an update on the further advances that are being made in treating NAFLD,
NASH and carried out a PubMed search using the MeSH Terms NAFLD; NASH; HCC;
Preventive or curative therapies.
We came across 377 articles out of which we chose 70 articles for updating the earlier
information we had reviewed.No meta-analysis was done.
L-Carnitine(LC) has a great part in oxidative metabolism as it is needed for moving Long Chain Fatty Acids (LCFA’s) from the cytoplasm into the mitochondrial matrixin which β-oxidation takes place. For getting shifted these LCFA require activation into acyl CoA’s and get converted into acyl carnitines for movement across mitochondrial membrane. These acyl carnitines are under C22 in length can get into mitochondrial matrix [12], where get exchanged with free carnitine, they get converted back to acyl CoA’s and thus can get utilized for β-oxidation [13]. Alsocarnitine is needed for shifting the end products of peroxisomal β-oxidation,medium as well asshort chain acyl CoA’s,out of the peroxisomes for promotingmoremitochondrial processing [14]. Decrease in carnitine amounts correlates with Insulin Resistance (IR) as well as Diet Induced Obesity (DIO) and was pointed to be secondary to prolonged lipid excess, impaired energy metabolism,associated with fat oxidation that is not complete [15].On the other hand, LC administration in obese rats was demonstrated to reinstate carnitine amounts and thereby enhancing metabolic working [15] (Figure1).
Nicotinamide Ribose (NR) is a molecule present within diet that is supposed to be
the molecule that is responsible for synthesis of nicotinamide adenine nucleotide (NAD+)
which increases oxidative metabolism and in mice has been demonstrated to protect
HFD induced obesity within mice [16]. Reducing equivalents are supplied by NAD+ for
oxidative phosphorylation,that is necessary for oxidative metabolism as well as metabolic homeostasis .In obesity along with other components of Metabolic
Syndrome (MetS) like Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) as well as
NAFLD [17,18], pointing that with external supplementation to
escalate NAD+ levels might help in reducing these conditions.Further
NAD+ helps in avoiding extent of injury secondary to Oxidative Stress
(OS) [17]. In Obesity as well as NAFLD formation role of Oxidative
Stress (OS) has been documented [19]. An escalation of 4-hydroxy
nonenal (4-HNE), that represents a marker of Oxidative Stress
(OS)-stimulated lipid peroxidation [20] which takes place in NAFLD
subjects [21,22]. Thus Salic et al. analyzed if giving a combination
of l-Carnitine (LC) and Nicotinamide Ribose (NR), both parts of
natural substances which might increase transfer of FA’sinside
mitochondrial membrane and thus enhance NAD+) amounts, that
are known to be essential for β-oxidation as well as tricarboxylic acid
cycle(TCA) respectively (Figure 2). Ldlr-/-Leiden micegot treated
With High Fat Diet (HFD) that had administration of (LC;0.4%w/w),
(NR;0.3%w/w) or both (COMBI) for 21 weeks. Levels of LC that
were decreased by HFD got to normal after LC administration.
Similarly with NR administration increased its plasma amounts of
metabolism products suggesting proper administration. Inspite of
food orally along with locomotion were relatively same in all groups,
COMBItherapy markedly ameliorated HFD stimulated enhancement
of body weight,fat mass increase which was -17% as well as hepatic
steasosis that reduced by 22%. Further, both NR and COMBI
decreased liver 4-HNE adducts. On checking the upstream regulator gene analysis showed that COMBI finished the negative actions of
HFD on liver metabolism pathways correlated controllers like ACOX,
SCAP, SREBP, PPARGC1B and INSR. Thus a combination therapy of
LC and NR confers protection on metabolic paths and might reflect a
prospective therapy for obesity caused by HFD as well as NAFLD [23].
Figure 1: Courtesy ref number16 -Schematic representation of mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation in humans
Description: :Long-chain fatty acids enter the cell from the bloodstream and enter the mitochondria through the carnitine shuttle, followed by a step-wise degradation involving a series of enzymes of the long-chain fatty acid oxidation machinery resulting in the production of acetyl-CoA. Potential treatments to produce acetyl-CoA independent of the fatty acid oxidation enzymes are indicated. These include medium-chain triglycerides, ketone bodies and triheptanoin. Abbreviations: CI-V, Complex I-V; CACT, Carnitine Acylcarnitine Translocase; CD36, Cluster of Differentiation 36; CoA, Coenzyme A; CPT1, Carnitine Palmitoyl Transferase type 1; CPT2, Carnitine Palmitoyl Transferase type 2; FABP pm, plasma membrane-associated Fatty Acid Binding Protein; FATP, Fatty Acid Transport Protein; LCEH, Long-Chain Enoyl-CoA Hydratase; LCHAD, Long-Chain 3-Hydroxyacyl-CoA-Dehydrogenase; LCKAT, Long-Chain Ketoacyl-CoA Thiolase; MCAD, Medium-Chain Acyl-CoA Dehydrogenase; MCKAT, Medium-Chain 3-Ketoacyl-CoA Thiolase; OCTN2, Organic Cation Transporter 2; SCAD, Short-Chain AcylCoA Dehydrogenase; SCHAD, Short-Chain 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA Dehydrogenase; T2, acetoacetyl-CoA thiolase.
Figure 2: Courtesy ref no-13Schematic representation of the different actions of NR in metabolic homeostasis
Description: The scheme summarizes the hypothesis by which
NR supplementation would increase NAD+ content in key
metabolic tissues, leading to SIRT1 and SIRT3 activation and the
deacetylation and modulation of the activity of key metabolic
regulators. This model does not rule out the participation of
additional mechanisms of action for NR to achieve its beneficial
effects. Abbreviations can be found in the text and enzymes are
indicated in italics.
Figure 3: Primary bile acids are synthesized from cholesterol in
the liver, via either the classical pathway, which produces CA, or
the alternative pathway, which produces CDCA, or, in mice only,
α- or β-MCA.Bile acids are conjugated with glycine or taurine
(predominantly taurine in mice) before being released into the
bile [30]. In the gut, bile acids are deconjugated and metabolized
into secondary bile acids (UDCA is considered a secondary bile
acid in humans but a primary bile acid in mice). About 95% of
bile acids are reabsorbed from the gut and transported back to
the liver via the hepatic portal vein, and the remainder is excreted.
The hydrophilicity of the common free and conjugated bile salts
decreases in the order UDCA > CA > CDCA > DCA) > LCA, and
taurine-conjugated > glycine-conjugated > free species. ASBT
inhibition with volixibat blocks the reabsorption of bile acids and
increases their excretion, stimulating the liver to synthesize more
bile acids from cholesterol. ASBT: apical sodium-dependent bile
acid transporter, CA: cholic acid, CDCA: chenodeoxycholic acid, Cyp:
cytochrome P450 family, DCA: deoxycholic acid, G: glycine, HDCA:
hyodeoxycholic acid, LCA: lithocholic acid, MCA: muricholic acid, T:
taurine, UDCA: ursodeoxycholic acid
Nonalcoholic Steato Hepatitis (NASH) represents a severe and mostly propagating type of NAFLD [24-26] for which no approved medical therapy exists pointing to severe need for developing one [27]. On histology, hepatic steatosis, lobular inflammation with damage of the liver cells injury or ballooning that causes cell necrosis either with or without fibrosis [28]. Since classically NASH remains silent a liver biopsy is needed to pick it up early [28,29]. It might cause cirrhosis, Hepatocellular Carcinoma (HCC), [30] as well as liver failure [31,32], being the biggest cause for liver transplantation in US adults below 50years [33]. There is complicated pathophysiology of NASH along with multifactorial [reviewed earlier by us unpublished, under review] having multiple factors in combination like genetic, environmental, Gut Microbiota (GM),. Additionally dysfunctional metabolism of bile acids, lipids that include cholesterol as well as Insulin Resistance (IR) [34].Excessive synthesis as well as decreased excretion of cholesterol from liver ends up in the collection of free cholesterol [35] that correlates with hepatic injury, mainly via interfering of mitochondrial function [36] as well as facilitation of Oxidative Stress (OS) [37].
Escalated serum insulin as well as triglycerides associated with increased amounts of Very Low Density Lipoproteins (VLDL) cholesterol and decreased High Density Lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol [37,38]. In NASH subjects IR as well as hyperlipidemia is frequent just like visceral obesity accompanied with MetS [24]. White Adipose Tissue (WAT) enhancement might aid in disease propagation via synthesis of adipokines, inflammatory cytokines as well as lipids [39].
Commonly serum bile acids are increased in NASHsubjects, with levels 2 times >than normal [40]. With bile acids amounts elevated inflammatory responses might present with Oxidative Stress (OS),cell death paths that might lead to liver injury [41,42]. Primary bile acids get manufactured via cholesterol in the liver and shifted to gut via bile where they might be metabolized to secondary bile acids by bacteria (Figure 3) [38,43]. Secondary bile acids like Lithocholic Acid (LCA) and Deoxy Cholic Acid (DCA), have > hydrophobicity [42,43] and might stimulate inflammation, enhance Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS),and stimulate necrotic pathways [42-44].
Although the rates are constantly escalating we don’t have any effective therapy but for diet changes and exercise [25,45]. Lot of pharmacological therapies that hold a promise is being studied [45]. One strategy is to block the enterohepatic recirculation of bile acids back to liver by blocking the Apical Sodium Dependent Bile Acids Transporter (ASBT) [46]. The ASBT is a transmembrane protein present in the luminal surface of ileal enterocytes.Roughly 95% of the bile acids pool gets resorped in the terminal ileumand then shifted back to liver, and the rest gets excreted via feces [43,47] (Figure 3).
Blocking bile acids recycling via inhibition of ASBT enhances the fecal excretion [46,48] and is believed to induce the liver for more bile acids manufacture from hepatic cholesterol for sustaining the bile acids homeostasis [49].In mice inhibition of ASBT escalated hepatic expression of cholesterol 7α hydroxylase (Cyp 7a1) [49], a rate limiting enzyme in bile acids manufacture [50,51]. Volixibat Potassium (SHP26,earlier called LUM002 now labeled Volixibat), a minimally absorbed ASBT inhibitor [46,52] was partly used for a phase 2 clinical study in patients with NASH (ClinicalTrial.gov) Identifier NCT02787304 in parallel with the below described mouse study by Salic et al. [53].
Hence Salic etal. tried to test the probable disease ameliorating
action of ASBT inhibitor volixibat (5,15 and 30mg /kg) in HFD fed
Ldlr-/-Leiden mice over 24 weeks .Plasma as well as fecal bile acids
amounts, plasma insulin ,lipids , liver enzymes were evaluated.
Ultimate examination was liver histology, intra hepatic lipids,
mesenteric WAT mass as well as liver gene profiles testing. Volixibat
escalated the total amount of fecal bile acids. At the maximum dose
, Volixibat significantly ameliorated the HFD stimulated increased
hepatocyte hypertrophy, liver triglycerides as well ascholesteryl ester
levels as well as mesenteric WAT getting accumulated. Nonalcoholic
fatty liver diseases scores (NAS) were significantly low in Volixibat
treated mice act HFD controls. Gene profiling demonstrated that Volixibat finished the inhibitory action of HFD on metabolic
controllers like peroxisome proliferator activated peroxisome
proliferator activated receptor – ƴ coactivators (PGC1s), insulin
receptor as well as sterol regulatory element binding transcription
factor 2. Thus Volixibat might be effective physiologically as well as
regarding metabolic part of NASH pathophysiology [53].
Globally the incidence of metabolic disorders like Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Diseases (NAFLD), Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM), as well as obesity has presented in anepidemic fashion worldwide. NAFLD incidence is 6-35% (median 20%) worldwide with this number escalating worldover, in view of the diet andlifestylepatterns [54]. This NAFLD prevalence is markedly associated with obesity, T2DM as well as dyslipidemia [55]. The ‘’multiple hit hypothesis’’ is thought to be responsible for the etiopathogenesis of NAFLD, that includes IR, Adipose Tissue(AT) liberated hormones, nutritional factors, GM as well as genetic and epigenetic factors [56,57]. As NAFLD progresses simple steatosis might shift to the more severe form labeled Nonalcoholic Steatohepatitis (NASH) that includes inflammation as well as apoptosis, with or without fibrosis as well as cirrhosis. No proper way of avoiding the occurrence and formation of NASH exists other than diet control.Discovery of new drugs for curing NAFLD and NASH will be very important.
For treating these chronic problems Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) have been utilized for long in Chinaas well assome Asian countries for centuries. As no medical therapy from West has been shown to be safe and efficacious for treating NAFLD, Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) pose a particular superiority.Silybin is extracted from milk thistle (Sylibummarianum) seeds and is used as a hepato protective agent broadly [58]. Different potential biological actions of Silybin have been looked for, that includes cancer therapy, DM treatment and liver diseases therapy [59,60]. Mode of action includes control of lipid metabolism,antioxidant radical scavenger. Cellular membrane getting stabilized and promotion of ribosomal and RNA synthesis [61,62] has also been documented that silybin manipulated variety of metabolism pathways in acute liver injury [63]. But no metabolism information of Silybin has been totally given that might give us understanding of its mechanism of action.
Metabolomics gives information in a comprehensive manner
that regarding endogenous molecules in the body and is very useful
in diagnosing the variety of diseases for decreasing the chances
of these conditions [64,65]. Moreover biomarkers are used in an
unbiased way to for classification of the stage of disease propagation
[65,66]. It also lends biomarkers to check the effectiveness of drugs,
also labeled as pharmacometabolomics [67,68]. Serum biomarkers,
like total cholesterol, triglycerides. C peptide and Glucose Tolerance
Test (GTT), have been utilized in diagnosing NAFLD for several years.
Right now there are more upcoming biomarkers giving important
complementary knowledge, like Apo lipoproteins A1, apolipoprotein
B leptin, adiponectin, Free Fatty Acids (FFA), ghrelin and Tumor
Necrosis Factor Alpha (TNFα) [69]. But a comprehensive and a total
view of metabolites that are altered in NAFLD and following Silybin
therapy is not available. Hence Sun et al. [70] tried to evaluate the
metabolic control by Silybin of NAFL D.C57BL/6J mice that were given
HFD/High cholesterol diet for 8wks and treated with Silybin (50 or
100mg/kg/day) as well as sodium taurourso deoxycholate (TUDCA,
50mg/kg/day) by gavage for the last 4 weeks. Blood biochemical
indexes and hepatic lipid measurement along with Oil red O staining
of the liver were carried out for analyzing the model as well as the
lipid decreasing effect of Silybin and TUDCA. Moreover serum and
liver samples were checked utilizing a metabolomics platform on
the basis of gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC/MS).
Multivariate/univariate data analysis and pathway evaluation were
utilized for evaluation of different metabolites as well as metabolic
pathways. As per the results the mouse NAFLD model got established
successfully and Silybin and TUDCA decreased both serum as well as
hepatic lipid collection at significant levels. Metabolomics evaluation
of serum and liver demonstrated that HFD/High cholesterol diet led to the anomalous metabolism of metabolites participating in lipid
metabolism, polyol metabolism, amino acid metabolism, the urea
cycle and the TCA cycle. Silybin and TUDCA therapy together reversed
metabolic disorders produced by HFD feeding. Thus concluding that
a HFD/High cholesterol diet resulted in anomalous metabolism in the
serum and liver of mice, and Silybin therapy improved hepatic lipid
collection and manipulated global metabolic pathways that gave a
probable way for the multiple target modes of action [70].
Thus, here we have summed up the role of utilizing LC and NR
for affecting lipid metabolism by enhancing LC levels and with use
of NR how OS is reduced along with reduction of 4-hydroxy nonenal
(4-HNE) levels following increase of nicotine adenine diamide on
supplementing LC and NR together that might be one strategy for
reducing propagation of NAFLD. The further role of Apical Sodium
Dependent Bile Acids Transporter (ASBT) inhibitor volixibat by
affecting bile acid metabolism that is undergoing phase 2 trials in
humans for NASH and further the role of Silybin a product that has
been and rosmarinic acid we have researched from TCM. Already
probiotics, work on Vitamin D Metabolism, allylisothiocyanate
reviewed along with role of the gut microbiota in aetiopathogenesis
etc. Hopefully we will find some permanent method for prevention
of NAFLD, NASH propagating to cirrhosis HCC, liver failure and avoid
need of liver transplantation with incidence increasing with epidemic
of obesity and Diabesity and diabetes itself being a causative factor in
NAFLD as well as NASH independent of obesity.
Copyright © 2020 Boffin Access Limited.